How to Avoid Overpaying for a Car Repair at the Dealer

by Own the Dollar

car repair dealerDealing with a broken-down vehicle is difficult to say the least. Not only are you without transportation, but you also have to figure out which repairs are vital and if the shop’s quote is reasonable. While your first priority may be to get your car fixed asap, the worry that you’re overpaying could be enough to drive you off the deep end.

Many people prefer to have their car serviced and repaired at a certified dealership. This is great, except for one problem. Dealerships overcharge their customers. Right?

Fortunately, there are several steps you can take to ensure you are not being overcharged at the dealership, and that the dealer is truly doing what they say.

1. See the Problem With Your Own Eyes
Don’t take the dealer’s world for it. Instead, ask them to show you the problem they claim exists. Even if you don’t understand what you are looking at, you can learn more about the problem at hand, which will help you better understand your bill as well as any future issues.

Recently, I needed to have my back brakes replaced as one of the pads was “hanging up.” I never heard of this before and was a bit skeptical, so I asked the service manager to show me what he was talking about. Sure enough, the pad was hung up and wearing unevenly. In this instance, I was being told the truth. But how did I know for sure until I saw it myself?

2. Before Agreeing, Ask for a Cost Breakdown
Your dealer is going to charge you for both parts and labor. Before you agree to the repair, ask to see an itemized invoice that shows the labor rate as well as the cost of the parts.

Pay special attention to how much the parts cost, as this can differ substantially from one dealer and mechanic shop to the next. If you get the feeling, or know, that this cost is higher than it would be elsewhere, tell the dealer to hold off for a bit while you move forward with the steps below.

3. Take Your Car to an Independent Mechanic
Dealer service departments are not the end-all when it comes to car repairs. There may not be as many third part mechanic shops as there used to be, but these do exist in most parts of the country.

If your car is drivable, take it to a mechanic that you trust (or one that has been referred to you). Even if you cannot drive it, you can always call the mechanic on the phone to explain your situation and the quote you received.

4. Call Another Dealer
There are five Honda dealerships in my local area. I could take my Accord to any one of them for service. While you might expect them to all charge the same, this is actually not the case.

Did you know that the service department works independently from the sales side of the business? Just as salesmen are doing their best to make money, the service department is doing the same.

Before you sign on the dotted line and the repair process begins, call at least one other dealer in the area – of the same manufacturer – and ask what their costs would be for a similar job. Since you already have the itemized breakdown, you can tell them exactly what you need.

Final Thoughts
I am the type of person who would rather go to a dealer for repairs than a third-party mechanic. That being said, I am always careful about what I pay for.

It is a myth that the dealer always overcharges for service and repairs. But it does happen all the time. By following the above advice, you can avoid the many issues that have plagued thousands of people before you.

Grab Our RSS Feed! Receive Posts By E-mail


My Wealth Desire January 23, 2013 at 6:25 am

I agree with you bringing your car to the dealer service center than third party mechanics or a repair shop, this will give you a peace of mind. You are assured that all materials or parts are 100% genuine and it will not charge much. They will give high quality of work and warranty of service and parts being replaced.

My Financial Independence Journey February 18, 2013 at 7:28 pm

I would add to start asking around about good mechanics before you need to get your car looked at. One of the first things I did when I moved here was ask if anyone could recommend a mechanic. I drive and old car, and as such, regular repairs are guaranteed. I don’t know if I have the best mechanic around, but at least I have someone that none of my coworkers have had problems with.

Pam@Pennysaverblog March 21, 2013 at 5:02 pm

Doing a bit of your own research before going to the shop can help, because if they think you know something about the problem, they will likely have more respect for you and will be less likely to take advantage of you.

Hanover May 14, 2013 at 6:00 am

Totally agree with you. My independant mechanic is like 50% cheaper than one of the “authorized” mechanics.

[email protected] May 25, 2013 at 4:21 pm

It’s really important to see the problem with your own eyes. Over the years, I learned to never trust the dealers, you have to check the problem yourself !

Mechanic Melbourne October 24, 2013 at 1:30 am

Yes, most of the car dealers cheat us by saying there was a big problem that need to solve immediately. But there was a small servicing needed. So finding trustworthy and affordable car service center are really very important. Also we should learn some simple car service methods so we can save our money.

Marcus Dowey February 10, 2014 at 3:21 am

I am glad to be here and read the all good tips provided by you regarding of Car repairing . You consider all the main points which are essential for a car repairing . Thank you so much for sharing it .

Alex February 24, 2014 at 12:49 pm

My car’s 4 year free-maintenance program is ending soon, do you recommend taking it to the dealer where I bought the car for maintenance/repair after the program ends or I should shop around for a good auto body shop. I might pay more if I go to the dealership but at least I’m paying for good service without the guess work?

John @ FirstStepFinance July 7, 2014 at 7:27 am

Most of the car traders deceive us by saying there was a big issue that need to fix instantly. But there was a little maintenance required. Thanks for providing all excellent guidelines offered by you regarding of Car fixing .

John @ Wild AboutFinance July 12, 2014 at 9:13 pm

I am grateful to be here and study the all excellent guidelines offered by you regarding of Car fixing . You consider all the details which are important for a car fixing . Thank you so much for discussing it .

Tony @ Investing Track September 14, 2015 at 8:30 am

I never service my car at the dealership. I have a friend who’s an independent mechanic so I get pretty good rates.

tina@ Pro Finance Blog  January 10, 2016 at 12:50 am

Truth is its not possible to learn all about a car. 🙂 And as @Mechanic Melbourne said you need to search a trustworthy and affordable car service center in your locality if you don’t prefer Car dealers. Yes, they charge extra more. Always try to conform about the issues in your car and If they suggest for the replacement of any part then do some online research about the price. And also ask your mechanic to return back all removed part of your car.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Copyright © 2007–2023

WordPress Admin